Unraveling the Controversy Behind One Piece’s Best Parent Vote
The One Piece fan community is in the midst of a heated debate, resembling the unpredictable waters of the Grand Line. A controversial tier list, attempting to rank the best mothers and fathers in the series, has sparked waves of disagreement.
Artur’s Rankings Stir the Pot
Popular One Piece theorist Artur recently threw fuel on the flames with his ranking of the series’ best parental figures. Chapter 1101 brought Monkey D. Dragon into a new light, elevating his standing among fans. However, choices like Doflamingo’s father Homing, Robin’s mother, Shanks, and Rogers faced significant objections. Toki, Momonosuke’s mother, was deemed a failure, and Kuina’s father, Koushirou, a deadbeat – both seemingly due to events beyond their control.
Scrutinizing Artur’s Expertise
Netflix’s interest in Artur’s One Piece knowledge highlights its depth, yet even the maestro showed fallibility by revising his positions. The fan debate centers around the balance of ‘positive portrayal’ versus ‘positive actions’ by the characters.
For instance, Dragon earned praise as a decent father for prioritizing Luffy’s safety, while Robin’s mother, Nico Olvia, faced criticism for similar actions. Homing, despite leaving the Celestial Dragons to protect his children, was labeled a bad father, with fans arguing his responsibility for Doflamingo’s villainy. In contrast, Oden’s virtuous warrior pride escaped fan backlash, despite leading to tragedy for his family and country.
One Piece Fathers in Shonen Context
The discussion extends beyond One Piece, delving into the broader context of shonen fathers. It’s a common trope for the main character’s father to be absent, symbolically and narratively. A recent Fortnite clip featuring Vegeta resurfaced this conversation, echoing moments in Dragon Ball Z where absent fathers return in crucial moments.
Fan Favorites: Best Parents in One Piece
Determining the best parent in One Piece is subjective, with fans holding diverse opinions. Some popular choices include:
- Saint Roswald
Noted for his caring and supportive nature, Saint Roswald stands out among the best parents. Fans appreciate his depth and commitment to family values.
- Tom
Praised for dedication and imparting valuable life lessons, Tom’s role as a mentor and parent earns him a place in fans’ hearts.
- Kyros
Celebrated as a loving and supportive parent, Kyros endears himself with his commitment to family, resonating with those who admire his caring role.
The Diverse Rankings Continue
Other figures like Garp, Nefertari Cobra, Neptune, Otohime, Kozuki Oden, Toki, and Portgas D. Rouge receive recognition for various reasons. Garp’s strength, Cobra’s wisdom, Neptune and Otohime’s caring nature, Oden and Toki’s love and dedication, and Rouge’s emphasis on freedom contribute to their positions in fan rankings.
Subjectivity Rules
It’s crucial to note these rankings are rooted in fan opinions, showcasing the richness of the One Piece world and its diverse characters. There’s no definitive “best” parent, as preferences and experiences vary among fans.
The 5 Best Dads and 5 Who Aren’t So Great
One Piece offers a spectrum of fathers, from exemplary to questionable. Let’s delve into the world of fatherhood in One Piece.
Best: Pound
Despite being one of Charlotte Linlin’s many husbands, Pound’s love for his daughters, Lola and Chiffon, is undeniable. His unfortunate end only amplifies his commitment to family.
Not Great: Outlook III
Sabo’s noble upbringing under Outlook III’s strict rule contrasts with the warmth of his friendship with Luffy and Ace. Outlook III’s disapproval paints him as a less-than-ideal father figure.
Best: Neptune
King of Fish-man Island, Neptune, exemplifies strength and love as a father to Ryuboshi, Manboshi, Fukaboshi, and Shirahoshi. His protective instincts extend beyond family.
Not Great: Donquixote Homing
Homing’s deviation from Celestial Dragons’ lifestyle results in tragedy for his family. His wife succumbs to illness, and surviving family members endure a harrowing experience.
Best: Kyros
Once a gladiator, Kyros transforms into a loving father during Doflamingo’s assault on Dressrosa. His strength and devotion make him a standout dad.
Not Great: Vinsmoke Judge
Leader of the Germa Kingdom, Judge’s scientific experiments showcase a lack of paternal affection. Sanji’s escape highlights Judge’s disregard for familial bonds.
Best: Whitebeard
Desiring family over treasure, Whitebeard’s crewmates attest to the genuine fatherly bond he fosters. His willingness to wage war for his sons solidifies his place among the best dads.
Not Great: Monkey D. Dragon
Leader of the Revolutionary Army, Dragon’s absence defines his less-than-ideal parenting. His mysterious nature leaves Luffy yearning for a conventional father-son relationship.
Best: Zeff
Veteran pirate turned mentor, Zeff rescues Sanji, showcasing the positive influence of a fatherly figure.
Not Great: Yasopp
A member of the Red Hair Pirates, Yasopp’s pursuit of desires leads to abandonment of his son, Usopp. Their relationship reflects its complexity.
Final Thoughts
Navigating One Piece opinions reveals a sea of dissent. The diverse range of fathers enriches the narrative, reflecting familial complexities in a world of adventure and treasure.
